Crowd Disasters - by event type

(updated 16th January 2006)

 


Stampedes

"Crowd forces can reach levels that almost impossible to resist or control. Virtually all crowd deaths are due to compressive asphyxia and not the "trampling" reported by the news media. Evidence of bent steel railings after several fatal crowd incidents show that forces of more than 4500 N (1,000 lbs.) occurred. Forces are due to pushing, and the domino effect of people leaning against each other.

"Compressive asphyxia has occurred from people being stacked up vertically, one on top of the other, or horizontal pushing and leaning forces. In the Ibrox Park soccer stadium incident, police reported that the pile of bodies was 3 m (10 feet) high. At this height, people on the bottom would experience chest pressures of 3600-4000 N (800-900 lbs.), assuming half the weight of those above was concentrated in the upper body area.

"Horizontal forces sufficient to cause compressive asphyxia would be more dynamic as people push off against each other to obtain breathing space. In the Cincinnati rock concert incident, a line of bodies was found approximately 9 m (30 ft) from a wall near the entrance. This indicates that crowd pressures probably came from both directions as rear ranks pressed forward and front ranks pushed off the wall.

"Experiments to determine concentrated forces on guardrails due to leaning and pushing have shown that force of 30% to 75% of participant weight can occur. In a US National Bureau of Standards study of guardrails, three persons exerted a leaning force of 792 N (178 lbs.) and 609 N (137 lbs.) pushing. [9] In a similar Australian Building Technology Centre study, three persons in a combined leaning an pushing posture developed a force of 1370 N (306 lbs.). [10] This study showed that under a simulated "panic", 5 persons were capable of developing a force of 3430 N (766 lbs.)."  From Furin "Causes and Prevention of Disasters"


As part of our on-going research into crowd dynamics we have compiled a set of accidents/incidents from around the world. It needs to be highlighted that the Jamarat Bridge has over 2.5 Million Pilgrims PER DAY performing the stoning (lapidation) ritual. Stadia, by comparison may have 50,000 - 80,000 per event. When you compare the safety record of the Jamarat Bridge to a modern stadia you can see the alarming statistics relating to crowd dynamics and crowd safety.

Summary of the event related death/injuries (crowd related). We include the fires that result in death or injury where mass evacuation is involved.

We've compiled a summary list (see below) - but it should be noted that this list is far from complete - all details should be independently checked if you intend to use this information for research/analysis.

YearStadiumDeadInjuredReligiousDeadInjured
1988Katmandu (Nepal)93100   
1989Hillsborough (UK)96400   
1990Mogadishu (Somalia)718Al-Mu'aysam Tunnel (Saudi Arabia)1426 
1991Orkney (South Africa)4050   
 Nairobi (Keyna)124   
1992Bastia (Corsica)171900   
 Rio de Janerio (Brazil) 50   
1993      
1994   Jamarat Bridge (Saudi Arabia)26698
1995Freetown (Sierra Leone)  40   
1996Lusaka (Zambia)978   
 Tripoli (Libya)50    
 Guatamala 83180   
1997   Jamarat Bridge (Saudi Arabia)2243
1998   Jamarat Bridge (Saudi Arabia)118434
1999Alexandria (Egypt) 11Kerala (India)51100
2000Harara (Zimbabwe)12    
 Monrovia (Liberia)3    
 São Januário (Brazil) 200   
2001Lumbumashi (Congo)8 Jamarat Bridge (Saudi Arabia)35179
 Ellis Park (South Africa)47155Pak Patten (Pakistan)36150
 Ghana (West Africa)126    
 Ivory Coast (Africa)139   
2002      
2003   Nasik (India)32100
2004   Srirangam (India)51 
    Jamarat Bridge (Saudi Arabia)249252
2005   Wai (India)300 
2005   Iraq - stampede1000 (?) 
2006   Jamarat Bridge363289
      
YearHotelDeadInjuredConcertDeadInjured
1988      
1989Sydney6    
1990Miami (USA)924   
 Sheraton (Cairo)1870   
1991      
1992      
1993Paxton (USA)19    
1994Wakagi (Japan)5 MTV Europe (Poland)7 
 Antwerp Switel (Belgium)15160Art Palace (Taiwan)